Classic gastronomic restaurant
Destination-level cooking rooted in an established classical repertoire.
Proposal: this category competes in the combined field gastronomic-destination.
Who can take part
Restaurants open to the public for at least 12 months before the judging period, serving a cooked menu at destination level.
Who competes against whom
Other destination and tasting-menu restaurants in the same geography. Never against neighbourhood, specialist or quick-service places.
How quality is documented
At least two anonymous, self-paid visits by different assessors in the judging period, plus a verified menu and price.
Criteria and weights
Proposed scoring sheet - to be reviewed and approved by the jury chair before it is used. Once judging starts, the approved version is frozen for that edition.
| Criterion | Weight | 1 | 3 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Taste and cooking | 35 % | Flavours unbalanced, technique faults that reach the plate | Precise, balanced cooking without faults | Deep, clear flavours and technique that the field measures itself against |
| Ingredient quality and use | 20 % | Weak or tired produce, poorly handled | Good produce, handled with respect | Outstanding produce used with understanding of season, origin and waste |
| Consistency across visits and servings | 15 % | Clear variation between visits or dishes | Same level across visits and dishes | Exactly the same high level every time, under any pressure observed |
| Execution and identity of the concept | 10 % | Unclear or poorly executed concept | The concept is clear and delivered | A strong, coherent identity carried through every detail |
| Service in relation to the concept | 10 % | Service works against the experience | Service fits the concept and works | Service lifts the experience - measured against the concept, not against luxury |
| Value in the local price and market context | 10 % | Poor value for the local market | Fair value for the local market | Remarkable value for the local market at its price level |