Method
Draft method, version 1.0. It will be reviewed by the founding jury before nominations open. Any later change gets a new version number; results always keep the rules they were judged under.
1. What is awarded
The Golden Cutting Board recognises places (restaurants, food places, bakeries, drinks venues, artisan shops, institutional kitchens), people (from chefs and sommeliers to kitchen porters and buyers), teams, initiatives and - in bounded competitions - single dishes and products. Each award names its category, its area and its year: Golden Cutting Board · Pizza Restaurant · Copenhagen · 2027.
2. Like is compared with like
Every candidate is described along separate dimensions: type of business, cuisine, service form and level of ambition, price level in the local market, geography, external distinctions and kind of candidate (place, person, team, initiative). The competition field is built mainly from ambition level, concept and service form. A neighbourhood pizzeria never competes against a tasting-menu restaurant.
External distinctions such as a Michelin star are recorded as dated, sourced facts (guide, edition, year). They inform the description, but they do not decide the category: a sushi counter with a star can still compete as a sushi restaurant.
The catalogue of categories is a toolbox. In a season only categories with a real field of candidates, real judges and documentable quality are activated, in a named area. No international award is given on a field that in practice covers one city or a few countries.
3. How quality is documented
- Places are assessed through anonymous visits paid for by the awards, at least two by different assessors for any significant jury award. Where another form is used (an announced visit, a practical test, a tasting), it is stated openly.
- Individual crafts (for example saucier or pastry chef) are assessed through a practical test or tasting of the person's own work under set conditions, together with verified statements from colleagues or the workplace. A job title in a contract is not required: the work is what counts.
- Initiatives (waste, sourcing, accessibility, workplace development) need separate, verifiable evidence: measurements, supplier data, certificates. A business's own marketing is never enough.
- Online reviews, followers and media attention are not evidence of quality. Several nominations of the same candidate are merged into one; the number of nominations does not improve the assessment.
4. Scoring
Each category has a scoring sheet with weighted criteria and descriptive anchors for the scores 1, 3 and 5, so that judges read the scale the same way. A criterion can be marked not observed; it is then left out, never counted as zero. An assessment is valid only when the observed criteria carry most of the weight. Across assessors the median is used, so one outlier cannot carry or sink a candidate, and a large spread sends the candidate back to the jury for discussion. Every assessment records the assessor, the date, the form of assessment, the rules version and a written justification.
Public results show the decision and the jury's reasons - not decimals that would suggest a precision no judging has.
5. Jury and conflicts of interest
The roles are jury chair, judges, visiting assessors, category editors, verification staff, administrators and an independent control function. Every judge declares conflicts of interest: current or recent employment, ownership, financial ties, close personal relations, paid collaborations and direct competition. A judge with an excluding conflict cannot assess that candidate - the system refuses it. The names of the jury chair and judges are published after the season; the identities of anonymous assessors are protected.
6. Decisions
A jury decision requires the documentation the category demands, the number of valid independent assessments it demands and, for a person, the person's own acceptance of the nomination. Before a winner is decided, the independent control checks that the procedure was followed; the person deciding cannot also check the procedure. No category has to have a winner: it can end as not awarded, insufficient field, insufficient documentation or postponed.
7. Jury awards and People's Choice
The two are separate. Public votes never affect a jury award unless a method published before the season says so explicitly. A People's Choice winner is always labelled as such. Votes are confirmed by e-mail, one per address and category; suspicious patterns are flagged and reviewed by hand, and campaigns offering incentives for votes disqualify the votes concerned.
8. Money
Taking part is free, and so is the basic use of a legitimate winner's emblem. Nominations, finalist places and wins are never sold, publication is never paid for, and no payment improves a candidate's position. Physical trophies, extra diplomas and event tickets are optional and have no influence on any result. Sponsors are named with their scope; they never see confidential jury notes and have no say over candidates or winners.
9. Use of AI
AI helps with research, structure, translation, summaries, quality checks and administration, and always states its sources, uncertainty and what it could not confirm. AI never visits a restaurant, never claims to have tasted anything, never invents interviews, nominations or recommendations, never chooses a winner and never replaces the required evidence with online buzz. It does not contact candidates, judges or sponsors outside an approved communication process.
10. People, privacy and job changes
A person is never shown publicly as nominated before they have accepted, and their profile is their own: an employer cannot take it over or block it without a factual reason. Only the information needed is collected; confidential references have restricted access. An award stays with the person if they change jobs, and the award always states which workplace and period it concerns.
11. Corrections and complaints
Factual errors, procedural errors, undeclared conflicts of interest and eligibility can be raised and are reviewed. The jury's professional judgement itself is not reopened. Corrections and withdrawals are shown on the award's verification page, with the date and the reason.
12. Rules versions
Criteria and weights are stored for each edition. When judging starts they are frozen; later changes create a new version and never rewrite the basis of earlier results.