THEGOLDEN CUTTING BOARD
places

Grill and barbecue

Proposed combined field for grill restaurants and smokehouses.

Who can take part

Places whose menu is built around one speciality, open for at least 12 months. A place may also hold a dated external distinction (e.g. a Michelin star); that does not move it out of its specialist field.

Who competes against whom

Places with the same speciality in the same geography. A tasting-menu restaurant whose speciality is incidental is not eligible.

How quality is documented

At least two anonymous, self-paid visits by different assessors that cover the speciality itself.

Criteria and weights

Proposed scoring sheet - to be reviewed and approved by the jury chair before it is used. Once judging starts, the approved version is frozen for that edition.

CriterionWeight135
Taste and cooking35 %Flavours unbalanced, technique faults that reach the platePrecise, balanced cooking without faultsDeep, clear flavours and technique that the field measures itself against
Ingredient quality and use20 %Weak or tired produce, poorly handledGood produce, handled with respectOutstanding produce used with understanding of season, origin and waste
Consistency across visits and servings15 %Clear variation between visits or dishesSame level across visits and dishesExactly the same high level every time, under any pressure observed
Execution and identity of the concept10 %Unclear or poorly executed conceptThe concept is clear and deliveredA strong, coherent identity carried through every detail
Service in relation to the concept10 %Service works against the experienceService fits the concept and worksService lifts the experience - measured against the concept, not against luxury
Value in the local price and market context10 %Poor value for the local marketFair value for the local marketRemarkable value for the local market at its price level

Scale 1-5: 1 = Clearly below the standard of the competition field · 2 = Below the field, with real weaknesses · 3 = Solid and correct for the field - no notable weaknesses · 4 = Clearly above the field · 5 = Exceptional - a reference for the field. "Not observed" is always possible and never counts as zero; an assessment is valid only when the observed criteria carry at least 75 % of the weight.

Seasons and areas

Not running in any season yet.