Sommelier
A person responsible for wine and other drinks service with guests.
Who can take part
A person working in the role (whatever the local title) for at least 12 months of the judging period, who accepts the nomination.
Who competes against whom
People in the same role in the same geography, across all kinds of venues. A simple, excellent guest experience counts as much as an elaborate one.
How quality is documented
At least two anonymous observations during normal service by different assessors, plus a verified colleague or employer statement.
Criteria and weights
Proposed scoring sheet - to be reviewed and approved by the jury chair before it is used. Once judging starts, the approved version is frozen for that edition.
| Criterion | Weight | 1 | 3 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Understanding of the guest | 25 % | Misreads guests | Reads guests correctly | Anticipates guests without intruding |
| Professional knowledge | 20 % | Gaps that reach the guest | Sound knowledge | Deep knowledge, shared at the right level |
| Communication | 20 % | Unclear or inappropriate | Clear and appropriate | Natural, warm and precise |
| Precision | 15 % | Errors in timing or detail | Correct timing and detail | Flawless timing and detail |
| Handling of challenges | 10 % | Problems escalate | Problems are solved | Problems become good experiences |
| Teamwork | 10 % | Works alone or against the team | Works with the team | Makes the whole team better |