Outstanding Wine Programme
A venue's wine list and wine service.
Who can take part
A business, kitchen or organisation with a documented initiative running for at least 12 months.
Who competes against whom
Initiatives in the same geography, judged relative to the size of the business.
How quality is documented
At least two anonymous, self-paid visits and a verified list.
Criteria and weights
Proposed scoring sheet - to be reviewed and approved by the jury chair before it is used. Once judging starts, the approved version is frozen for that edition.
| Criterion | Weight | 1 | 3 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quality in the glass or cup | 35 % | Faults | Correct and good | Reference level |
| Selection and sourcing | 20 % | Thin or careless | Thoughtful | Outstanding and well sourced |
| Knowledge and guidance | 15 % | Weak | Sound | Deep and generous |
| Consistency | 10 % | Varies | Holds | Identical every time |
| Hospitality in relation to the concept | 10 % | Works against the experience | Fits | Lifts the experience |
| Value in the local market | 10 % | Poor | Fair | Remarkable |